Free Comparison Tool

Roofing Material Comparison

Compare roofing materials side-by-side. Select 2-4 materials to see how they stack up on cost, lifespan, wind resistance, insurance impact, and more.

Select Materials to Compare (2-4)

FeatureArchitectural ShinglesStanding Seam Metal
Cost/sq ft$4.50-7.00$10.00-18.00
Lifespan (FL)20-30 years40-70 years
Wind Rating110-130 mph140-170+ mph
InsuranceStandard15-35% discount
EnergyMediumExcellent
Impact RatingClass 3-4 availableBuilt-in
Fire ClassAA
Weight240-350 lbs/sq100-150 lbs/sq
FL Score8/109/10

Architectural Shingles

Pros

  • + Best value for FL
  • + 130 mph wind options
  • + Algae resistant
  • + Impact ratings available
  • + Lifetime warranty

Cons

  • - 20-30 year max in FL
  • - UV degrades faster than metal
  • - Will need replacement
Full guide

Standing Seam Metal

Pros

  • + Best hurricane protection
  • + Longest lifespan
  • + Energy efficient
  • + Insurance savings
  • + Zero maintenance
  • + Lightweight

Cons

  • - Highest upfront cost
  • - Specialized installers needed
  • - Can dent (aluminum)
Full guide

Not Sure Which Material Is Right?

Every home is different. Get a free on-site assessment with material recommendations specific to your property, budget, and goals.

Get Free Quote

How to Use This Comparison Tool

Select 2-4 roofing materials from the buttons above to see them compared side by side. The "FL Score" represents our overall recommendation rating for Florida/Pinellas County homes based on hurricane performance, longevity, insurance impact, and value.

For detailed information on any material, click its name in the comparison table to read the full guide. Or use our roof cost calculator to estimate pricing for your specific home size.

Want an even more personalized assessment? Try our "Do I Need a New Roof?" quiz to evaluate your current roof's condition, then come back here to compare replacement options.

Get Your Free Quote